Friday 31 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Comedy Review: Convicted (Pinder, Wight, Choyce and Davies / PBH’s Free Fringe)

ED2012 2/5 Reviews ED2012 Comedy Reviews

The boisterous ‘Convicted’ MC interacts with his audience well, while skilfully introducing this showcase of mainly Australian talent to the Fringe. Unfortunately his line-up is a mixed bag. Likeable but nervy, Sian Choyce offered a slightly shaky observational set that lurched a little too awkwardly from topic to topic, though there were kernels of great promise when she got it right. Guest act, Danish bagpiper Claus Reiss, filled the stage with a calm, wry wit and genuine musical talent. But none of this could save a show that concluded with Nellie Wight’s crude, sexually graphic jokes. Her ten minutes were unconvincing, and made it hard to be impressed by ‘Convicted’ overall. Though, to be fair, perhaps the time slot was wrong, Wight’s act might just work in a late night slot with a more appropriate heading; I’d suggest ‘An Introduction To Pornography’.

Cabaret Voltaire, 4-24 Aug (not 15, 22), 2.35pm.
tw rating 2/5 | [Sarah Macartney]


  • ThreeWeeks in Edinburgh 2015 – we’re back for year 20!
  • ThreeWeeks Podcast Edition 08: Wrap Up
  • Photo Shoot: Editors’ Award winners
  • ThreeWeeks Editors’ Awards 2014 presented
  • Morgan & West: A subtle kind of magic
  • Tom Neenan: The incident at the Half Moon Inn (A Fringe ghost story)