Friday 31 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Comedy Review: George’s Marvellous Medics (St George’s Medics Revue)

ED2012 2/5 Reviews ED2012 Comedy Reviews

It started off so well. Kicking in with a fantastic medical rendition (it is a Medic’s Revue after all) of Gilbert & Sullivan’s ‘Modern Major General’, ‘George’s Marvellous Medics’ looked very promising. Unfortunately, too many cooks spoil the broth, or in this case too many actors spoil the show. Although there is some obvious talent on display here (Dr Wilcox was great), it is somewhat underdeveloped, and overall, the acting is sketchy acting and the writing is poor; too often, a sketch ended with a damp slap as opposed to a proper punch-line, leaving the audience in a clapping limbo. I wanted to like this, I really did, but the quality is just too erratic to recommend this as a medicine for your boredom.

theSpace @ Surgeon’s Hall, 20-25 Aug, 6.05pm.
tw rating 2/5 | [Joseph Trotter]


  • ThreeWeeks in Edinburgh 2015 – we’re back for year 20!
  • ThreeWeeks Podcast Edition 08: Wrap Up
  • Photo Shoot: Editors’ Award winners
  • ThreeWeeks Editors’ Awards 2014 presented
  • Morgan & West: A subtle kind of magic
  • Tom Neenan: The incident at the Half Moon Inn (A Fringe ghost story)