Friday 31 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Comedy Review: Stephen Carlin – Pandas Vs. Penguins (Bound And Gagged Comedy By Arrangement With Glorious Management)

ED2012 2/5 Reviews ED2012 Comedy Reviews

When you are performing in a venue as prestigious as the Pleasance Courtyard, average will not suffice; a show must be pretty good to not look out of place, and unfortunately ‘Pandas Vs. Penguins’ is neither amusing nor insightful enough to deserve your investment of time and money. At best, it’s mildly diverting background noise that will raise gentle titters for an hour, then be forgotten about almost instantaneously. It did not help that this show, largely concerning Scottish identity, was half-empty and that only one audience member resided north of Hadrian’s Wall. There are surely hundreds of worse shows at the Fringe, but when you are booked in at what is widely regarded to be one of Edinburgh’s better comedy complexes, the weight of expectation sometimes leads to disappointment.

Pleasance Courtyard, 4 – 27 Aug (not 14), 6.00pm .
tw rating 2/5 | [Joseph Fleming]


  • Lucy Benson-Brown: Cutting Off Kate Bush
  • Long list published for Fringe’s eco-award
  • 3 To See ED2014: Top Improv Comedy Tips
  • Edinburgh Comedy Awards judging panel confirmed
  • 3 To See ED2014: Musical Adaptations
  • Dan Schreiber: The idiot elf arrives at the Fringe