Tuesday 7 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Comedy Review: Tales From The Unaccepted (Ed Caruana, Elaine Mason, Gary Tro, Richard Todd and Sunil Patel)

ED2012 4/5 Reviews ED2012 Comedy Reviews

The top of a graffitied double-decker in the guts of the Cowgate; was I in the Fringiest venue on the Fringe? The bizarre location added a lovely intimacy to this two-set show hosted by the chatty and charming Elaine Mason, whose natural friendliness (and games… with prizes) turned us into a cheery afternoon audience. Next we were treated to Gary Tro’s endearing and self-deprecating exploration of failed romances, his warm wit overriding his slightly nervous energy. Surreal storyteller Richard Todd followed, and both his height and performance made him seem slightly too big for the bus – his animated, haphazard comedy could easily fill a theatre. Despite frequent talk of “no punchlines,” this warm, unpolished and genuinely funny trio kept the whole crowd laughing.

Laughing Horse @ The Free Sisters, 2-12 Aug, 12.30pm.
tw rating 4/5 | [Sarah Macartney]


  • TW Podcast at the Edinburgh Festival 23.08.15
  • Three To See on 28 Aug: Michael J Dolan, Soweto Afro Pop Opera, Abnormally Funny People
  • ‘A Girl Is A Half-Formed Thing’ wins Amnesty prize
  • Ally Houston: Clowning with stand-up
  • Luke Wright: The stay-at-Fringe dandy
  • Eddie Nixon and Christina Elliot: Giving dance its place