Friday 31 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Comedy Review: The Top Secret Comedy Club (The Top Secret Comedy Club / PBH’s Free Fringe)

ED2012 3/5 Reviews ED2012 Comedy Reviews

Shows with a rotating line-up are always a gamble, and I guess this day I lost.┬áHost Rory O’Hanlan was personable and chatty, but his standard England vs Scotland vs Ireland routine wasn’t handled with much panache and really wasn’t all that fresh. Next up, Marcus Birdman’s thinly veiled hostility towards an audience who just weren’t warmed up yet sadly detracted from a potentially funny set. Matt Price, on the other hand, was more on the money, with endearingly amusing anecdotes and observations, but he made way for Pete Dobbing who quickly got distracted by his own stories and forgot about making the audience laugh. A definite case of better luck next time.

Whistlebinkies, 5-24 Aug (not 11, 18), 6.30pm.
tw rating 3/5 | [Rebecca Low]


  • TW Podcast at the Edinburgh Festival 28.08.15
  • International Festival fireworks to also finale the Fringe this year
  • Comedy awards flow at the Edinburgh Fringe
  • ThreeWeeks Editors’ Awards presented for 2015
  • Three To See on 29 Aug: Edmund The Learned Pig, The Remnants, Going Viral