Friday 31 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Theatre Review: Sherlock Holmes And The Sound Of The Baskervilles (Two Shades Of Blue)

ED2012 2/5 Reviews ED2012 Theatre Reviews

‘Sherlock Holmes And The Sound Of The Baskervilles’ is the sort of spoof that cries out for overblown, hammy performances but, sadly, only the delightfully rubber faced Gareth Smith as Watson pulls this off, with the remainder of the cast putting in rather insipid turns. The script is similarly patchy, with Watson’s narration and poor literary technique hitting the spot, but the rest of the jokes raising only chuckles where there should be belly laughs and the songs are only mildly, not uproariously, amusing. The central premise – that of Miss Marple framing Watson – is a decent one, and there are glimmers of what this show could have been had it show the required exuberance and wackiness.

Paradise at Augustine’s, 21 – 27 Aug, 2.20pm
tw rating 2/5 | [Andrew Bell]

OR READ MORE ABOUT: |

  • 3 To See ED2014: Theatre for Older Children
  • More spaces and more nova for the C Fringe this year
  • Lucy Benson-Brown: Cutting Off Kate Bush
  • Long list published for Fringe’s eco-award
  • 3 To See ED2014: Top Improv Comedy Tips
  • Edinburgh Comedy Awards judging panel confirmed
  •