Thursday 9 August 2012 | By

ED2012 Theatre Review: Treasure Island (SJC Productions)

ED2012 2/5 Reviews ED2012 Theatre Reviews

Skilful storytelling and enough conviction can transform an empty room into a ship, a tropical island or a cave full of treasure. It’s a shame, then, that SJC never quite convince, despite the enthusiasm they bring to Stevenson’s classic. An admirably faithful adaptation, their script would nevertheless benefit from tighter editing, as the production lacks the energy or ingenuity to stay afloat, repeatedly missing opportunities to enliven the familiar story. While the small ensemble play their parts to the hilt, they never quite hit the mark between serious characterisation and shiver–me–timbers, pseudo–Pugwash mugging. Relying too heavily on the audience’s imagination and too little on the company’s skill, this show founders soon after it leaves the harbour.

C too, 2 – 27 Aug (not 14), 3.30pm.
tw rating 2/5 | [Dave Fargnoli]


  • 3 To See ED2014: ThreeWeeks approved comedy
  • Guy Retallack: A musical retelling of the ‘thrill killers’ crime
  • ThreeWeeks preview edition is go!
  • 3 To See ED2014: Theatre for Older Children
  • More spaces and more nova for the C Fringe this year
  • Lucy Benson-Brown: Cutting Off Kate Bush